Comment 'Hi Alex,Sorry but I ...' to 'I still need insight on how to encode videos larger than 2gb.'
  • Hi Alex,

    Sorry but I have tested the following

    • Posting Update To Timeline
      • Encoding starts on cron.
      • Encoding will not start unless "Post" has been clicked. 
        • Uploaded a video and pressed "Post" straight after upload and it started to encode when cron ran after posting.
        • Uploaded a video a waited 3 minuets for encoding to start. Cron ran 3 times and the video did not encode. One pressed "Post" the video started encoding straight away once the next cron ran.
      • Have to wait for video to finish encoding before watching.
      • Do not get an update of video encoding.
    • Posting a Post
      • Encoding starts on cron and before clicking "Post".
      • Can start watching before the video is encoded.
      • Do not get a update that the video is finished encoding.
    • Discussions
      • Video don't encode at all. And if it don't encode and we can watch it straight away can't that be done for Updates, Posts and Albums.
      • Attachment has no thumbnail.
      • Video works straight away.
      • On timeline it don't show that the discussion has a video attached. Might be handy to show it has. 
      • On Post you can insert media, maybe do this for videos in discussions.
    • Albums
      • Encoding starts on cron and before clicking submit.
      • Have to wait for video to finish encoding before watching.
      • Do not get an update of video encoding.

    I do like that discussions bypass encoding, to be honest, I wish videos did not need encoding at all, it would save on CPU resources allowing for UNA to be run on low-end servers. And also videos would be instant. 

    I understand it's for compression and encryption, but I would be happy to have the media stored on a secure data storage server or similar to keep the data safe and as for compression I would be happy to sacrifice space to bypass FFMPEG. 

    • Thank you for checking, yes, it looks like videos start to transcode upon submit only in some modules, thank you for stating this. 

      Actually Discussions don't have video encoding at all, video file can have different codecs and most of them aren't playable in web browser, so transcoding is required to make videos playable in browser, also it makes sure that videos have consistent resolution and quality to be playable using average internet connection speed.