Hi Nathe, are you using Lucid? Anyways i just added post to feed block(#1) and i can choose practically everyone on the site, but post to public feed(#2) i can only choose public visibility.  I only added both to test, but if i disable #2 and create a post it disappears from home page. If i disable #1 and enable #2 the post that is created does appear on home page.