No Alex, the problem is not that.
1 .. If you create a profile with Dolphin Connect, the default permission for the profile is "Me Only".
Member must then go modify in his profile, but he does not because he believes his profile is visible.
2. When the visibility of profile X is on "Only Me", Y wants to visit its profile from member list, nothing happens. Y do not understand why.
That is why I said that there should be an alert for this case.